Why Are We Testing Newborns for Pot?

Posted on November 29, 2012. Filed under: Drug War, LATEST | Tags: , , , , , |

The science is alarmingly inconclusive, but the punishment for mothers is severe.

November 23, 2012  |  

Employees at US hospitals are testing more and more newborns for cannabis exposure. And, with alarming frequency, they are getting the wrong results. So say a pair of recent studies documenting the unreliability of infant drug testing.



In the most recent trial, published in the September edition of the Journal of Clinical Chemistry , investigators at the University of Utah School of Medicine evaluated the rate of unconfirmed "positive" immunoassay test results in infant and non-infant urine samples over a 52-week period. Shockingly, authors found that positive tests for carboxy THC, a byproduct of THC screened for in immunoassay urine tests, were 59 times less likely to be confirmed in infant urine specimens as compared to non-infant urine samples. Overall, 47 percent of the infant positive immunoassay urine samples evaluated did not test for the presence of carboxy THC when confirmatory assay measures were later performed.
Immunoassay testing – the standard technology used in workplace drug testing – relies on the use of antibodies (proteins that will react to a particular substance or a group of very similar substances) to document whether a specific reaction occurs. Therefore, a positive result on an immunoassay test presumes that a certain quantity of a particular substance may be present in the sample, but it does not actually identify the presence of the substance itself. A more specific chemical test, known as chromatography, must be performed in order to confirm any preliminary analytical test results. Samples that test positive on the presumptive immunoassay test, but then later test negative on the confirmatory test are known as false positives.
False positive test results for cannabis’ carboxy THC metabolite are relatively uncommon in adult specimens. Among newborns’ specimens, however, false positive results for alleged cannabis exposure are disturbingly prevalent.
In April, researchers at the University of North Carolina reported in the journal Clinical Biochemistry that various chemicals present in various baby wash products, such as Johnson’s Head-to-Toe Baby Wash and CVS Baby Wash, frequently cross-react with the immunoassay test to cause false positive results for carboxy THC.

“[The] addition of Head-to-Toe Baby Wash to drug-free urine produced a dose dependent measureable response in the THC immunoassay,” the investigators concluded . “Addition of other commercially available baby soaps gave similar results, and subsequent testing identified specific chemical surfactants that reacted with the THC immunoassay. … Given these consequences, it is important for laboratories and providers to be aware of this potential source for false positive screening results and to consider confirmation before initiating interventions.”

Following the publication of the UNC study, researchers at the University of Utah screened for the presence of baby soap contaminants in infant urine. Surprisingly, they didn’t find any . Rather, they concluded that the disproportionately high rate of false positive test results discovered among their samples were the result of a cross-reaction with some other yet-to-be determined constituent. They cautioned: “Until the compounds contributing to positive urine screen results in infants are identified, we encourage the use of alternative specimens for the detection and investigation of neonatal exposure to cannabinoids. Screen-positive cannabinoid results from infant samples should not be reported without confirmation or appropriate consultation, because they cannot currently be interpreted.”
Yet despite these warnings, in many instances, hospitals fail to confirm the results of presumptive drug tests prior to reporting them to state authorities. (Because confirmatory testing is more expensive the immunoassay testing, many hospitals neglect to send such presumptive positive urine samples to outside labs for follow-up analysis.) Ironically, such confirmatory tests are required for all hospital employees who test positive for illicit substances. But presently, no such guidelines stipulate that similar precautions be taken for newborns or pregnant mothers. Explains Lynn Paltrow, executive director of National Advocates for Pregnant Women : “NAPW has had calls from numerous parents who were subjected to intrusive, threatening, and counterproductive child welfare interventions based on false or innocent positive test results for marijuana. We have learned that pregnant patients receive fewer guarantees of accuracy than do job applicants at that same hospital.” 

Regardless of whether or not the drug screen results are confirmed, the sanctions for those subjects who test positive are often swift and severe. Typically, any report of alleged infant exposure to cannabis will trigger a host of serious consequences ranging from the involvement of social services to accusations of child endangerment or neglect. In some instances, mothers whose infants test positive for carboxy THC will lose temporary child custody rights and be mandated to attend a drug treatment program. In other instances they may be civilly prosecuted. At least 18 states address the issue of pregnant women’s drug use in their civil child neglect laws; in 12 states prenatal exposure to any illegal drug is defined by statute as civil child abuse. (One state, South Carolina, authorizes the criminal prosecution of mothers who are alleged to have consumed cannabis, or any other illicit substance, during pregnancy and carry their baby to term.) 
Of further concern is the reality that the hospital staff’s decision to drug test infants or pregnant mothers appears to be largely a subjective one. There are no national standards delineating specific criteria for the drug testing of pregnant women, new mothers, or their infants. In fact, the only federal government panel ever convened to advise on the practice urged against its adoption. As a result, race and class largely influence who is tested and who isn’t. A study published in the  Journal of Women’s Health reported that "black women and their newborns were 1.5 times more likely to be tested for illicit drugs as non-black women," after controlling for obstetrical conditions and socio-demographic factors, such as single marital status or a lack of health insurance. A separate study published in the New England Journal of Medicine reported similar rates of illicit drug consumption during pregnancy among both black and white women, but found that “black women were reported [to health authorities] at approximately 10 times the rate for white women.”
How many mothers have been accused of child neglect or abuse because of false positive drug test results? Nobody knows for sure. But no doubt some mothers have been penalized solely as a result of the test’s inherent fallibility – and many more are likely to face similar sanctions in the future. That’s because the practice of drug testing infants for cannabis exposure remains a relatively popular even though there exists limited, if any, evidence to justify it.
“No child-health expert would characterize recreational drug use during pregnancy as a good idea,” writes Time.com columnist Maia Szalavitz. “But it’s not at all clear that the benefits, if any, of newborn marijuana screening – particularly given how selectively the tests are administered – justify the potential harm it can cause to families.”
Richard Wexler, executive director of the National Coalition for Child Protection Reform agrees, telling Time.com that the emotional damage caused by removing an infant child from their mothers, as well as the risk of abuse inherent to foster care, far outweigh any risks to the child that may be caused by maternal marijuana use during pregnancy. 
In fact, the potential health effects of maternal marijuana use on infant birth weight and early development have been subject to scientific scrutiny for several decades. One of the earliest and most often cited studies on the topic comes from Dr. Melanie Dreher and colleagues, who assessed neonatal outcomes in Jamaica, where it is customary for many women to ingest cannabis, often in tea, during pregnancy to combat symptoms of morning sickness. Writing in the journal  Pediatrics in 1994, Dreher and colleagues reported no significant physical or psychological differences in newborns of heavy marijuana-using mothers at three days old, and found that exposed children performed better on a variety of physiological and autonomic tests than non-exposed children at 30 days. (This latter trend was suggested to have been a result of the socio-economic status of the mothers rather than a result of pre-natal pot exposure.)
Separate population studies have reported similar results. A 2002 survey of 12,060 British women reported, “[C]annabis use during pregnancy was unrelated to risk of perinatal death or need for special care.” Researchers added that “frequent or regular use” of cannabis throughout pregnancy may be associated with “small but statistically detectable decrements in birthweight.” However, the association between cannabis use and birthweight failed to be statistically significant after investigators adjusted for confounding factors such as the mothers’ age, pre-pregnancy weight, and the self-reported use of tobacco, alcohol, caffeine, and other illicit drugs.”


Read Full Post | Make a Comment ( None so far )

  • Archives

  • RSS USMJParty

    • Marijuana makes mother nature cry: report June 27, 2015
      06/26/15 05:17 PM facebook twitter 1 save share group 37 By Tony Dokoupil     If you consume cannabis this weekend, you might also be killing fish, clear-cutting forest, and poisoning some cute-faced and endangered members of the weasel family. That’s one takeaway from new report in the journal BioScience, which details the water-guzzling, land-destroying, [ […]
    • Marijuana and Your Job: What You Need to Know June 27, 2015
      Carolyn Buppert, MSN, JD Disclosures June 26, 2015   To submit a legal/professional nursing question for future consideration, write to the editor at syox@medscape.net (Include "Ask the Expert" in subject line.) Question Can I be fired for using marijuana at home or for using recreational marijuana on my day off, when recreational use is legal […] […]
    • Rand Paul set to raise money from marijuana industry June 27, 2015
      By Sam Youngman syoungman@herald-leader.comJune 26, 2015 Updated 2 hours ago U.S. Sen. Rand Paul is looking for big green from the marijuana industry. Paul, Kentucky’s junior senator and a candidate for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination, is scheduled to attend a fundraising reception next week at the National Cannabis Business Summit and Expo in De […]
    • 400-plus People Running for U.S. President June 26, 2015
              Friday, June 26, 2015 :: Staff infoZine By Quentin Misiag – Thirteen Republicans. Four Democrats. Washington, DC – infoZine – Scripps Howard Foundation Wire – A growing list of contenders have tossed their hats in the political ring for the 2016 race to the White House. But the official tally spans […]
      http://www.cms.gov/medicare-cover…/…/icd-9-code-lookup.aspx…& ICD-9 Code Lookup Find an ICD-9 Code by searching on keyword(s). cms.gov Like Comment Share Sheree Krider ICD-9 Code ICD-9 Code Description 304.30 CANNABIS DEPENDENCE UNSPECIFIED USE 304.31 CANNABIS DEPENDENCE CONTINUOUS USE 304.32 CANNABIS DEPENDENCE EPISODIC USE 304.33 CANNABIS DEPENDENCE IN […]
    • Marijuana addiction drug research gets $3 million grant as Obama encourages legalization June 26, 2015
      By Kelly Riddell – The Washington Times – Thursday, June 25, 2015     The National Institutes of Health is dedicating $3 million to fast-track the development of drugs to treat marijuana addiction — an estimated 4.2 million Americans are hooked on cannabis — even as the president encourages its legalization and more states look […]
    • Texans poll overwhelmingly in favor of reduced pot penalties June 26, 2015
      Originally posted on Texas Cannabis Report:A scene from earlier this year in Fort Worth as thousands marched through downtown in support of changing marijuana laws in Texas. Fresh off of a hot legislative session featuring 11 bills pertaining to marijuana, a new poll shows that Texans are overwhelmingly in support of reducing the penalty…
    • Texas sets new record for largest marijuana growing operation June 26, 2015
      Originally posted on Texas Cannabis Report:A marijuana grow room at a dispensary in Colorado. After authorities in east Texas were alerted by a hunter to a field containing just over 100,000 marijuana plants last year, setting an all time record for a marijuana growing operation in the state, this year the record has been…
    • DJ Gary Ganja Hopes To Hit New High With ‘Music For Stoners’ June 26, 2015
      Originally posted on CBS Denver:DENVER (CBS4)– It claims to be the first radio station of its kind in the United States and its getting a lot of different listeners. “We’re like 420 friendly, we play music for stoners, we have marijuana comedy, this summer we’re giving away trips to Amsterdam and Jamaica,” Gary Ganja…
    • A pie made of coca leaves awaits the Pope when he visits Bolivia June 25, 2015
      Coca planters will be giving Pope Francis a pie and other goods made out of coca leaves, when he arrives next July for an official visit to Bolivia. The gifts will be delivered during the scheduled meeting of Francis wish social movements’ organization in Santa Cruz, according to the organizers.   Leonardo Loza, vice-president of […]
    • Man ‘hides stash of marijuana in Mary Jane candy wrappers’ but pot is detected inside checked bag by TSA at Newark airport June 25, 2015
      Originally posted on wchildblog:From Mail Online, Jun 2015 By MYRIAH TOWNER Gregory Murphy, 49, of Toms River, New Jersey made it past security and was waiting to board his flight when he was confronted by Port Authority police after TSA found the drugs, pictured above, in his checked bag A New Jersey man was…
    • Who Is A ‘Terrorist’? June 25, 2015
      Originally posted on wchildblog:Source: Antiwar.com, by Justin Raimondo The recent attack on a predominantly African-American church by a murderous racist has provoked a passionate debate about who is – and is not – a “terrorist.” According to FBI director James Comey, the perpetrator of the Charleston massacre – in which nine people were killed…
    • 45th Annual Smoke-In July 4, 2015 Washington, CO June 25, 2015
      Originally posted on Deadheads United™:Marijuana Activist Call To Action 45th Anniversary Smoke-In Saturday July 4th, 2015, Washington DC “Smoke-in Alumni Reunite!”   “This demonstration, held on the day that commemorates 45 consecutive years of Smoke-In history in Washington DC, is an opportune moment to acknowledge the era of change created by Marijuana Ac […]
    • Marijuana is medicine, Journal of the American Medical Association concludes June 25, 2015
      Posted on June 23, 2015 at 10:06 am by David Downs in featured, Health, Science Marijuana is one hundred percent a form of medicine, researchers conclude in a bombshell series of reports released today by the Journal of the American Medical Association. Cannabis — which has been used medicinally for thousands of years — reduces […]
    • Drug Tests Don’t Make Sense, So Why Are Employers Still Using Them? June 24, 2015
            The U.S. is experiencing a marijuana revolution. Four states, as well as Washington, D.C. have legalized marijuana by popular vote. There are now 23 states with medical marijuana laws. Much of this has happened in the past decade. Despite this, and the overwhelming wealth of knowledge related to the fact that marijuana […]
    • Campbell marijuana lab suspects jailed June 24, 2015
      Originally posted on WKBN.com:[anvplayer video=”531460″ /] CAMPBELL, Ohio (WKBN) – Three people arrested Monday after Campbell police found a marijuana growing operation in the basement of 540 Penhale Ave. are being held at the Mahoning County Jail. Richard Holloway, 19, is being held on $37,500 bond and is facing felony charges of cultivation…
    • Medication may stop drug and alcohol addiction June 24, 2015
      Originally posted on Engineering Evil:Public Release: 23-Jun-2015 University of Texas at Austin Researchers at The University of Texas at Austin have successfully stopped cocaine and alcohol addiction in experiments using a drug already approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to treat high blood pressure. If the treatment is proven effective […]
    • Medical marijuana ‘edibles’ mostly mislabeled, study shows June 24, 2015
      Originally posted on Engineering Evil:Public Release: 23-Jun-2015 “ Laboratory testing showed 44 products (59 percent) had detectible levels of CBD, but the average ratio of THC to CBD was 36-to-1” Review of small sample of dispensary products suggests buyers at risk of overdosing or being cheated Johns Hopkins Medicine In a proof-of-concept study, a…
    • Know Your Constitution June 24, 2015
          When in the course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect […]
    • ‘Embarrassingly Low’ Patient Count in Illinois a Big Concern for MMJ Businesses June 23, 2015
      By John Schroyer Scores of dispensaries are hoping to open in Illinois later this year, but they might face an immense challenge right out of the gate: a lack of customers. Illinois has approved just 2,500 patients for MMJ cards since opening the registry nearly nine months ago, which one attorney with ties to the […]
  • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 18,859 other followers

  • Blog Stats

    • 7,875 hits

Liked it here?
Why not try sites on the blogroll...


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 18,859 other followers

%d bloggers like this: